Are police officers’ lives worth more than other people’s? Some New York legislators think so

In the wake of recent murders of police officers in the state of New York, there is a legislative effort to allow the imposition of the death penalty in such cases.

Whatever one’s thoughts are regarding capital punishment, my real problem with this kind of legislation is that it, in effect, says that the value of one’s life is dependent to some degree on one’s profession. By imposing a harsher penalty for the killing of a police officer than for the killing of others, it says that a construction worker’s life, or a taxi driver’s, or a bartender’s (etc.) is worth less than the life of a police officer.

Assemblyman Tim Gordon, I-Bethlehem, is willing to co-sponsor Destito’s bill.

“I don’t support the death penalty, but it’s a special circumstance when people are shooting at police officers,” said Gordon, adding that his position has been influenced by the murder of Albany Police Lt. John Finn, who was shot and killed in 2003 by a parolee in Albany.

But why is it a “special circumstance”–or perhaps more accurately, why is the murder of someone else not a special circumstance? Are we to think of police as what David Codrea might call the “Only Ones” worthy of “blood for blood” justice?

“He knew he was shooting at a cop,” Gordon said. “When they’re knowingly shooting at police officers, it’s just too much.”

But it’s not “too much” to shoot at people who don’t work in law enforcement (or at people who do work in law enforcement, but the shooter is unaware of the fact)? Will a cop killer avoid death row if he can convince the jury that he thought his victim was a mere citizen, rather than a police officer?

I find such notions highly repugnant, and utterly contrary to the philosophical foundations on which this nation was built.


2 Responses to “Are police officers’ lives worth more than other people’s? Some New York legislators think so”

  1. Anonymous Says:

    Something about all men are created equal just deosnt seem to ring true anymore. I to am extremely tired or feeling that I am a 2nd class citizen simply because I am not a member of law enforcement or a government worker.

    Its time that something was done about these injustices.

  2. opaww Says:

    My problem with this is that it places value to human life based on classes.
    A politician is more valuable then a COP, and a COP is more valuable then a middle class citizen, and a middle class citizen is more valuable then a lower class (poor) person, ECT. Now should we add race in there? If so then which race is more valuable?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: